Pizza Making Mistakes

This page is an overview of the common mistakes people make when making Neapolitan style pizza (as instructed by famous pizza maker Enzo Coccia)

Dry Dough

Once you have prepared the dough, a common mistake is not covering it properly for bulk fermentation. Covering the dough ensures that the dough does not dry out. A dough that has dried out will produce a very tough dough, an uneven texture, and most importantly a dough that is not properly hydrated.

The Fix

After mixing and kneading the dough form your huge dough ball, put it in a bowl and cover it with a damp towel!

Tip

Wet your towel before you cover the dough. A damp towel will ensure that no moisture is lost in your fermentation.

Unleavened Dough

A dough that hasn’t risen will not give you the characteristic delicate, fluffy texture of a Neapolitan style pizza. It will be harder to work with and stretch out come pizza making time. You’ll notice the crust’s lack of fluffiness after it’s cooked too.

The Fix

Be sure that your yeast is alive, you have given the dough ample fermentation time, and that you’re letting the dough properly ferment at the appropriate temperature.

Cold Dough

A cold dough is non buono. A cold dough is when you take a dough directly from the refrigerator and immediately stretch it out, top it, and cook. You’ll find that like the other mistakes, it makes the dough difficult to work with, and also it will give you uneven cooking. Because it is cold, the crust will have improper spotting due to the temperature variations (also known as “measles pizza”) associated with a good Neapolitan style pizza.

The Fix

Allow your dough to come to room temperature before working with it.

Tip

Room temperature is defined here as between 70ºF and 78ºF (22ºC-25ºC).

Collapsed Dough

A collapsed dough is a dead dough. Basically a dough that has exceeded its “18 hour window of goodness”. You’ll notice the dough is thinner in the center when being prepared and that the gluten also does not have the same strength. A collapsed dough is a weak dough and is a result of over-fermentation.

The Fix

Follow your recipe’s allotted fermentation times. The Neapolitan style generally bulk ferments for 2 hours, separates into dough balls, and then allows for around 12 hours of secondary fermentation.

Tip

If you’re going to ferment it for a long time. Throw it in the fridge. This will slow down the yeast so that they don’t eat up all the sugars at once!

Wet Dough

An overly wet dough is a tragedy. It’s hard to work with and only the most talented pizza chefs can handle such a beast; however it’s still a very unpleasant situation. What will end up happening is that you’ll likely be adding way too much flour to the dough to get it to not stick. This is undesirable because raw flour burns on the crust which makes your pizza taste terrible.

The Fix

If you live in an especially humid environment, lessen your water amount in your initial fermentation. If not, tailor your moisture content to your oven temperature. If you’re baking at home you don’t need more than a 70% pizza dough. Stop putting so much water, this isn’t bread!

Tip

If you do everything right in your bulk fermentation, you won’t have to deal with a wet dough in the end.

Improper Cooking

There are two scenarios that can occur. Either the temperature is too low, or it is too high. If the temperature of the oven is too low, the pizza will have to stay in the oven longer, thus creating a dry, more crispy pizza. If the oven temperature is too high, then the pizza will burn! Nobody likes a burnt pizza. Unless you’re my uncle Vinny. We don’t talk to uncle Vinny.

The Fix

Keep your oven temperature between 806˚F - 869˚F (430˚C - 465˚C). This is the ideal temperature for the Neapolitan pizza.

Tip

If you’re cooking your pizzas in around 90 seconds, then you’re doing it right. If you’re doing anything more than that, then your oven isn’t hot enough.